Online Quit Clinics vs. GPs: Best for Quitting Smoking?

Quitting smoking is a challenging journey, and having the right support is essential to make it through successfully. In Australia, two main options for smoking cessation support are traditional general practitioners (GPs) and online quit clinics. Both options offer unique benefits and limitations, and understanding the differences can help people choose the support best suited to their needs.

‍

‍

Traditional General Practitioners (GPs) and Smoking Cessation

GPs are a trusted source of medical advice for millions of Australians. For those seeking support to quit smoking, GPs provide a personal and tailored approach. Many GPs are trained to offer smoking cessation support, including guidance on managing withdrawal symptoms, understanding triggers, and creating a personalised quit plan.

‍

- Face-to-Face Consultation: Seeing a GP in person allows for open communication, enabling patients to ask questions, express concerns, and build a trusting relationship. Studies show that the personal connection built during face-to-face consultations can increase adherence to a quit plan and lead to better outcomes (Australian Government Department of Health 2023).

‍

- Medical Evaluation and Prescription Access: GPs can evaluate patients for underlying health conditions that may affect the quitting process, such as anxiety or depression. If necessary, they can prescribe nicotine replacement therapies (NRT) or medications like varenicline or bupropion, which have been shown to assist with smoking cessation. This personalised medical approach is particularly valuable for those with complex health needs (Therapeutic Goods Administration 2023).

‍

- Accountability and Follow-Up: Regular check-ups with a GP can keep patients accountable. Follow-up appointments allow GPs to track progress, address challenges, and adjust treatment plans as needed. This ongoing relationship can be a motivating factor for many, providing continuous encouragement to stay on track.

‍

However, traditional GP visits have their limitations. Access to GPs may be challenging for those in rural or remote areas, and in-person appointments can be time-consuming and require advanced scheduling. Additionally, there are often out-of-pocket costs associated with GP visits, depending on the patient’s health insurance coverage.

‍

‍

Online Quit Clinics and Smoking Cessation

Online quit clinics are a newer option, designed to offer support through digital channels.

Many Australians have turned to these services due to their accessibility, flexibility, and often lower costs.

‍

- Convenience and Accessibility: Online quit clinics provide support through video calls, chat, and even text messages, making them more accessible to people in rural or remote areas. Patients can access support from home, work, or wherever they feel comfortable. This flexibility is especially beneficial for those who have limited time or difficulty visiting a GP in person (Australian Government Department of Health 2023).

‍

- Immediate and Ongoing Support: Online quit clinics can often provide more immediate assistance, with some services offering 24/7 support or instant access to counselors. For individuals experiencing sudden cravings or challenges, this immediate availability can make a significant difference.

‍

- Structured Programs and Digital Tools: Many online quit clinics offer structured smoking cessation programs, often using evidence-based techniques. Some include tracking tools, reminders, and progress monitoring, which can help keep patients motivated. According to recent studies, digital interventions have been effective in supporting smoking cessation, with online clinics seeing positive outcomes in patient success rates (National Health and Medical Research Council 2023).

‍

- Confidentiality and Privacy: For some individuals, the anonymity of an online setting can make them feel more comfortable discussing their struggles without fear of judgment. This confidentiality may encourage them to be more open and honest about their habits and challenges.

‍

While online quit clinics have clear advantages, they also face certain limitations. Since they rely heavily on technology, individuals without reliable internet access or digital literacy may find it challenging to use these services effectively. Additionally, some online clinics do not offer the same level of medical evaluation as a GP, which may limit access to prescription medications that could aid in the quitting process.

‍

‍

Comparing Effectiveness: What Studies Show

Research comparing traditional GP support and online quit clinics in Australia is ongoing. A study by the Australian Government Department of Health suggests that both approaches can be effective for smoking cessation, but the success often depends on the individual’s specific needs, preferences, and circumstances.For those who prefer face-to-face interaction and a comprehensive medical approach, seeing a GP may be more beneficial. On the other hand, those who value convenience, accessibility, and digital tools may find online quit clinics to be an effective alternative.

‍

‍

Choosing the Right Support

Ultimately, both traditional GPs and online quit clinics offer valuable resources for quitting smoking. GPs provide a personalised medical approach, while online clinics offer convenience and flexibility. It’s important for individuals to assess their needs, consider their access to resources, and decide which option aligns best with their lifestyle and quitting goals.For some, combining both options—seeing a GP for medical advice and using an online quit clinic for ongoing support—may be the most effective approach. With the right support, achieving a smoke-free life is possible.

‍

‍

References:

Australian Government Department of Health 2023, Quitting smoking with the help of healthcare professionals, Australian Government, viewed 5 November 2024, https://www.health.gov.au/topics/smoking-vaping-and-tobacco/quitting-support.

‍

Therapeutic Goods Administration (TGA) 2023, Nicotine replacement therapy and smoking cessation medications, Australian Government, viewed 5 November 2024, https://www.tga.gov.au/resources/smoking-cessation-medications.

‍

National Health and Medical Research Council (NHMRC) 2023, Digital health interventions for smoking cessation, Australian Government, viewed 5 November 2024, https://www.nhmrc.gov.au/research/digital-interventions-smoking-cessation.